Two Thrifted Sweaters, Two Handmade Pumpkins
![]() |
| Featured image AI-assisted with ChatGPT using my original project photo. Interior photos by BellaArt Creates. |
Hi my friends, how goes it?! Well, today, I’m sharing a new make! Last year, I dabbled in making fabric pumpkins on my new sewing machine and they came out okay…I mainly kept the smaller ones but the larger ones I ended up pulling apart at the end of the season to use the fabric in another project.
Well, this Fall, I made another fabric pumpkin and it was much better. But I’m not talking about that pumpkin in this post, but rather the two sweater pumpkins I just made. I’d been watching tons of the sweater pumpkin YouTube videos and shorts trying to figure out how to make them large.
On a visit to the local thrift store, I was searching for knitted sweaters because the pics I saw of those really looked so cute. I wanted two contrasting colors so I chose a charcoal brown and a lighter color like Oatmeal. So, I bought two sweaters for about $7.99 ea., and brought them home.
It would be several months before Fall, so we washed the sweaters and I kept them in my drawer until I was ready for them, which was a few days ago. What I didn’t realize when I bought the brown sweater was that it wasn’t as large as I needed. I guess I wasn’t paying close attention!
But, I went with it! I cut them both just under the neckline and armpits. But…yes “BUT” I made a 2nd mistake with the brown sweater, I cut too much fabric and that derailed the size I was going for. I can tell you, I was not a happy crafter at this point! Well, I kept going.
Next thing was sewing the end together, so I turned the sweater wrong side out and did a hand gathering stitch using one of my long needles and matching embroidery thread. I love this stitch so much so after reaching the end, I had to close it and I pulled as tight as I could without breaking the thread. After ensuring it was closed tight, I turned the sweater right side out to stuff it.
For stuffing, I chose a combo of Poly-Pellets for weight and Poly-fil for shaping. I put the pellets down first until I was satisfied and then added the Poly-fil. I broke the pieces up in my hands before putting them into the sweater because this helps prevent unwanted lumpiness. As I added the Poly-fil, I shaped the sweater into a pumpkin and stuffed it pretty good. I wanted an heirloom pumpkin shape (my favorite).
When all that was done, I again did that gathering stitch by hand on the top end and as I was doing that, the pumpkin shape was really forming into sections. That made the next step easier. After I secured the top, I used more embroidery floss to accentuate those sections that pumpkins normally have. I used a much longer needle for this step because now the pumpkin is larger and I’m going through fabric and poly-fil from top to bottom.
The brown pumpkin I finished first and while it didn’t turn out to be the giant size I was going for, it still turned out sooo cute! I let it sit on my craft table and admired it all night! LOL 😀
The next day, I made her big brother the oatmeal-colored sweater and I had learned my lesson so when I cut it I made sure to leave enough fabric for the oversized pumpkin size I wanted when I started this project. I repeated the same steps. Check out how the bottom looks when that gathered stitch is done!

For the stems, I had some bark from a thrifted item I bought a few years back. I kept it, and the pieces worked perfectly for these pumpkins. I stuck them in when I did my gathered stitching at the top so I wouldn’t have to use hot glue. And if I ever want to use them again, I can simply pull them out.


And, here’s where I styled them…they’re perfect on our coffee table. When I looked back at the scene while taking the pictures I realized something… had I made the brown sweater the size I originally wanted, it would have dominated the lighter pumpkin and possibly not worked for our small size coffee table.


I don’t like making mistakes, BUT I do like it when a mistake turns out to be a blessing and changes my mind about the vision I had. The end result couldn’t have looked better!
For stuffing, I chose a combo of Poly-Pellets for weight and Poly-fil for shaping. I put the pellets down first until I was satisfied and then added the Poly-fil. I broke the pieces up in my hands before putting them into the sweater because this helps prevent unwanted lumpiness. As I added the Poly-fil, I shaped the sweater into a pumpkin and stuffed it pretty good. I wanted an heirloom pumpkin shape (my favorite).
When all that was done, I again did that gathering stitch by hand on the top end and as I was doing that, the pumpkin shape was really forming into sections. That made the next step easier. After I secured the top, I used more embroidery floss to accentuate those sections that pumpkins normally have. I used a much longer needle for this step because now the pumpkin is larger and I’m going through fabric and poly-fil from top to bottom.
The brown pumpkin I finished first and while it didn’t turn out to be the giant size I was going for, it still turned out sooo cute! I let it sit on my craft table and admired it all night! LOL 😀
The next day, I made her big brother the oatmeal-colored sweater and I had learned my lesson so when I cut it I made sure to leave enough fabric for the oversized pumpkin size I wanted when I started this project. I repeated the same steps. Check out how the bottom looks when that gathered stitch is done!

For the stems, I had some bark from a thrifted item I bought a few years back. I kept it, and the pieces worked perfectly for these pumpkins. I stuck them in when I did my gathered stitching at the top so I wouldn’t have to use hot glue. And if I ever want to use them again, I can simply pull them out.


And, here’s where I styled them…they’re perfect on our coffee table. When I looked back at the scene while taking the pictures I realized something… had I made the brown sweater the size I originally wanted, it would have dominated the lighter pumpkin and possibly not worked for our small size coffee table.


I don’t like making mistakes, BUT I do like it when a mistake turns out to be a blessing and changes my mind about the vision I had. The end result couldn’t have looked better!




0 comments
I'd love to hear from you! Leave a comment and thanks for stopping by!